FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstract, dissertation, book

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 18 | 19 || 21 | 22 |   ...   | 26 |

«MUSICOLOGICA OLOMUCENSIA VII Univerzita Palackého v Olomouci Olomouc 2005 The present volume was submitted to print on 6 April 2005. Dieser Band ...»

-- [ Page 20 ] --

sions of the type “tasteless” are not used in relation to nature whether the object at hand is extremely beautiful or extremely ugly. We would certainly not say that a mountain or river is “tasteful;” it is possible to speak of tastefulness in relation to a garden or a park, but then the evaluation is of something that was created by a person.

Every educated person probably knows the adage of “De gustibus non est disputandum” – “There is no disputing about taste.” It is said that people are simply different and they either like or dislike various things. Based on the aforementioned adage, taste is a personal matter that is nontransferable and difficult to explain. This opinion thus represents one of the most extreme concepts of taste, whereas the concept of taste at the other extreme of the spectrum can be briefly characterized as the adoption, acceptance, and respect of the ruling norm that is the current determining factor for taste and tastefulness. As a result, both good taste and bad taste exist; the latter represents either ignorance of the norm or ignoring the norm. Of course there are numerous positions in between these two marginal concepts and this is one of the reasons why the concept of “taste” is inconsistent. The concept has also changed over time and thus now we should observe its evolutionary paths.

The possibilities for expressing one’s individuality through taste judgments were not very numerous at first and thus it is no coincidence that the problem of taste in early thinking on beauty and the arts was not truly stressed. Every individual was guided by the superiority of myths, gods, and supreme orders – the existence and general validity of intersubjective standards and values was accepted as being definite. Thinking along these lines continued through the Middle Ages and in a certain manner into the Modern Age as well; see, for example, the English aesthetics of sensuality during the 18th century and the German idealistic aesthetics during the 18th and 19th centuries. Within these ideological circles, the concept of “taste” was handled in relation to ethics and thoughts on society in general. The hermeneutic philosopher Gadamer4 believes that the key moment in the transformation of the concept of “taste” into a scientific term was its incorporation into the wider concept defined by the expression/concept of “Bildung.” In the aforementioned German philosophy, “Bildung” does not represent solely a narrow view of education but rather a concept of the creation and formation of human nature that is permeated by a wider and philosophically more significant new age humanism.

This includes not only the formation of spirit (Geist – ingenio) but also the formation of taste (Geschmack – gusto). An intellectual then has the freedom to disassociate from the matter at hand, the freedom to cognitively and deliberately differentiate and select,5 to select but on the basis of recognition and “voluntary” association with the opinions Hans-Georg Gadamer: “Wahrheit und Methode. Grundzüge einer philosophischen Hermeneutik” [“Truth and Method: Fundamentals of a Philosophical Hermeneutic”] (Tübingen, 1965).

There is however often a reduction of taste to the level of sensory satisfaction – refer to Gadamer’s references to the concepts presented by Baumgarten (gustus = iudicium sensitivum – gusto = sensory judgment), Tetens (Iudicium ohne Reflexion – judgment without reflection), and Kant (who writes of the sensory judgment of perfection); we also find reference to this concentration on the moment of sensual recognition in the work of Susanne K. Langer (Feeling and Form [New York, 1953], 14), which describes taste as a pleasant or unpleasant reaction to a sensory stimulus.

and judgments of competent authorities. Gadamer also mentioned the belief that there is a relationship between the start of a “Bildungsideal” and the disintegration of society based on class privileges and the creation of a “new” (bourgeois) society that is connected by shared ideals and lifestyles. “Good society” is then directly represented by a society of individuals with good taste.

This is thus in conflict with the concept that declares the subjectivity and arbitrariness of taste (refer to the relatively skeptical adage of “De gustibus non est disputandum”) and emphatically and knowingly declares taste to be the acceptance of social norms to which an individual’s tendencies and preferences can be and must be subjected and adapted.6 Taste is therefore something that can be personally acquired but at the same time is something external, something that does not always express an individual’s true nature.

Within this concept taste is defined primarily as the act of accepting or refusing and does not recognize any fluctuations; taste thus does not always know its reasons and does not take any different positions on taste into consideration. The existential characteristics of taste as perceived by this philosophically aesthetic concept are thus security (primarily given by agreement with “general” taste) and then also negativity (taste develops primarily as a result of abhorrence of the distasteful).7 Taste and taste judgments are also included within a wider sociological perspective by numerous other philosophically aesthetic schools of thought including of course Marxism.8 Even though the adage of “De gustibus non est disputandum” is very old, individual taste, as has already been indicated, is something that mankind attains through personal development. It is a difficult and gradual process to reach the point at which personal subjectivity is comprehended and can be developed; an individual very gradually confirms personal individuality through the freedom to accept or to refuse. As it was previously a necessity to “identify with,” it is now possible to be different. And it is specifically this area of lifestyle and the area of art within its framework that provided an environment appropriate for the application of personal differences and individuality. There was no threat of a direct conflict with the authorities, represented mainly by the church and the state, as was the situation in the area of religious beliefs, and sometimes even science, gradual expansion, new worlds and experiences, new schools of art and new personalities expanded the range of choices. Individual (but also confrontational group) taste is therefore possible on the increasing level of the complexity of social structure and its With consideration to the normative nature of taste, Kant allowed for the possibility of its cultivation: perfect taste would include all of the works created by geniuses.

For example, Jean Jacques Rousseau declared that he felt taste but never explained that differences in taste do exist or the basic agreement of “good tastes” (refer to the definition of “Goût” in the “Encyclopédie de la musique II” [“Dictionary of Music: Part II”] [Paris, 1959]).

For example, Sáva Šabouk in his book Jazyk umění (Prague, 1968) defined the wider structure of which taste is a component, as an “aesthetic ‘I’ perspective”. Within this perspective, he incorporated the ability to perceive forms, the relatively static grouping of aesthetic standards of “good taste,” the degree of agreement between personal value systems with current overall human valid positive values, and, at the same time, the openness of the structure, i.e., the ability to change the status quo (specifically art that interferes with the canons of “good taste”).

dynamics. The historical trend of emphasizing options and expressing individual taste does however have its limits, both social as well as psychological: the tendency to create and respect aesthetic standards continues even in the most modern era although it does have continuously newer and newer forms.

In order to briefly summarize this more or less historical excursion into the dual interpretation of the concept of “taste”, we must state that both interpretations exist in the form of a somewhat dialectical relationship of mutual incompatibility yet at the same time a state of mutual interconnectivity and influenced by their temporary victories and defeats.

Although the opinion that taste is arbitrary is quite common, it cannot be supported even by standard “common sense”: the relationship between ethnic, social, and other environmental factors, as well as education and age on the one hand and taste on the other, is all too apparent. If animals are determined by their biological structure, humans are determined primarily by social factors, i.e., belonging to a certain culture as represented by a wide and culturally specific system of norms; there is a specific interaction between each individual and his or her specific cultural environment. Even though the biological and psychological characteristics of humans have significant impact (uniting and at the same time individualizing), culture holds a superior position as individuality is determined primarily by upbringing and both the life and psyche of members of various cultures are guided by characteristic cultural patterns. These cultural patterns lie not only above and external to an individual but are directly within individual as well – they become apparent through the individual’s experiences and activities. Cultural determination is actualized within several spheres: within the significant social structures, in specific historically political situations within a society, and in microstructures. The higher level of structures forms an abstract “set of all options” but it is primarily the microstructures that have a specific influence over an individual, i.e., mainly family and various informal groups whose significant role in shaping opinions and attitudes, and thus taste as well, is extremely high.

As we seem to have entered the sphere of psycho-sociological problematics as connected with the concept of “taste,” let us incorporate several important thoughts from the psycho-sociological field in our discussion on aesthetics as well. Taste is one of the properties of personality (the French classicist Boileau-Despréaux even coined the famous phrase “style – that is the person”); it is also possible to state that taste is a personal manner of viewing reality, the expression of a person’s internal state through their selection.

A person’s taste is dependent on his motivational structures, on his attitudes, and on his preferences (taste is a certain form of preference – it represents preference within the area of aesthetic phenomena). It is possible to differentiate authentic taste from aspirational taste. Authentic taste originates from an individual’s needs – it expresses individuality;

aspirational taste is driven by a diversely motivated effort to conform to the ruling norm (this norm is generally set by the majority, but sometimes by the elite). When evaluating taste and taste judgments, there are often mentioned the consistency or, conversely inconsistency of taste (good taste in one area is not always accompanied by good taste in other areas; a certain level of consistency is naturally not only desired but actually occurs quite often), the rigidity of taste or, the flexibility of taste (rigid refers to taste that is limited and cannot be developed, but the optimal situation is a certain measure of flexibility, or elasticity, i.e., the ability to react adequately to even unfamiliar stimuli and to be able to embody them in an new taste norm, etc.), taste suggestibility (it has been proven that taste judgments are often made under the influence of “opinion leaders,” i.e., strong individuals from the surrounding environment; quite often they are directed and even manipulated by criticism, marketing strategies on the cultural property market and today, primarily as the consequence of mass media).

As far as musical taste is concerned, it is possible to establish three primary moments that share in the creation of musical taste and are incorporated within it. The first is the sphere of an individual’s musical experiences wherein the system of musical abilities represents only a limiting foundation and wherein the most important role (both positive and negative) seems to be emotionally accented musical experiences that occurred primarily during the formative period of development (more primitive and narrower taste seems to be cemented fairly early as opposed to sophisticated and flexible taste that is the result of unending evolution). The second sphere is external to music and is at the level of individual psychology. Complex interaction within this sphere includes elements such as personality characteristics (i.e. will, temperament, structure of abilities, etc.), developmental personality layers, types of motivational structures (inherent motivational dispositions, actual needs and the satisfaction of those needs, reactions to the quantity and quality of stimuli, etc.). Intelligence plays the role of an integrating element, which, in agreement with Piaget, we perceive as a structure that enforces certain forms for the contacts between a subject and objects within near or distant surroundings and its originality depends primarily on the nature of the forms that it creates for these purposes. The third sphere is cultural determination in the broadest sense of the word; it includes upbringing and education as the rational acceptance of the historical experiences of humanity. It can be surmised that it is from this third sphere that the basic outlines of the taste preferences of a specific individual are drawn (there are certain defined possibilities and limits), whereas it is in the first and second spheres (that is, within their interconnections) that the “personal index” of taste is embedded.

If we return to the more general question of the properties of taste and the use of

the characteristics of taste, specifically the bearers of the taste, then we must remember that the majority of used and possible characteristics of taste are of a polar nature:

good taste – bad taste, clear-cut – unclear, developed (mature) – undeveloped, selective (fine) – vulgar, certain – uncertain (this of course is not a full list of characteristics); we can observe variations in the values on a scale ranging from positive to negative. Pairs such as standard – eccentric and conservative – avant-garde, wherein valorization is not so unambiguous, are also possible.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 18 | 19 || 21 | 22 |   ...   | 26 |

Similar works:

«Goods and Virtues. B y Michael Slote. New York: Clarendon Press. 1983. Michael Slote's Goods and Virtues does not offer a synoptic treatment of the virtues or of personal goods, but instead proposes a corrective to certain widely disseminated treatments of those topics. Surprisingly, his finegrained approach makes no mention of Alasdair MacIntyre's work. Slote avers that a good deal of philosophical writing on goods and the virtues is a priori, and as so restrictive, falls short of actual moral...»

«COGNITIVE AGING AND SURVEY MEASUREMENT by Sonja Irene Ziniel A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Survey Methodology) in The University of Michigan Doctoral Committee: Professor Norbert W. Schwarz, Chair Professor Robert M. Groves Emeritus Professor Robert L. Kahn Associate Professor Frederick G. Conrad Research Scientist Steven G. Heeringa © SONJA IRENE ZINIEL ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation would have never been...»

«From the Pastoral to the Grotesque in Late Russian Realism, 1872-1899 Ani Kokobobo Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY © 2011 Ani Kokobobo All rights reserved ABSTRACT From the Pastoral to the Grotesque in Late Russian Realism, 1872-1899 Ani Kokobobo This dissertation argues that, during the last three decades of the nineteenth-century, at a time when, influenced by Mikhail...»

«Publication list Name: George Konstantinidis Publications in refereed journals and proceedings of International Conferences: A. Until 2004 1. Konstantinidis G., R.D. Tomlinson, H. Neumann Microhardness of CuInSe2, Philosophical Magazine Letters, Vol.57, No.2, p. 91, (1988).2. M. Yakushev, Konstantinidis G., M. Imaneh, R.D. Tomlinson The observation of near-surface deviations from stoichiometry in CuInSe2 crystals following chemical etching, Solid State Communications, Vol.65, p. 1079, (1988)....»

«BERLIOZ, HOFFMANN, AND THE GENRE FANTASTIQUE IN FRENCH ROMANTICISM A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Cornell University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Francesca Mary Brittan August 2007 © 2007 Francesca Mary Brittan BERLIOZ, HOFFMANN, AND THE GENRE FANTASTIQUE IN FRENCH ROMANTICISM Francesca Mary Brittan, Ph.D. Cornell University, 2007 Taking Berlioz’s Symphonie fantastique as its focus, this dissertation...»

«Herbert Hrachovec Alois Pichler (Eds.) Philosophy of the Information Society Proceedings of the 30. International Ludwig Wittgenstein Symposium Kirchberg am Wechsel, Austria 2007 Volume 2 Bibliographic information published by Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliographie; detailed bibliographic data is available in the Internet at http://dnb.ddb.de Gedruckt mit Förderung des Bundesministeriums für Wissenschaft und...»

«carl spaeter gmbh carl spaeter gmbh Spaeter Gruppe: Ausbildung duales Studium Carl Spaeter GmbH Personalabteilung Philosophenweg 17 47051 Duisburg Branche: Handel und Distribution Mitarbeiter: bundesweit ca. 1.700 Mitarbeiter Spaeter Duisburg: Willkommen SPAETER Duisburg. Wir handeln für Ihren Erfolg. SPAETER Duisburg und Hebels Stahlservice präsentieren sich vom 15. bis zum 18. März gemeinsam auf der Spaeter Bietigheim: Unternehmen CARL SPAETER GmbH CARL SPAETER GmbH. Höpfigheimer Straße...»

«Monitoring of Enzymatic Reactions using Capillary Electrophoresis with Conductivity Detection Inauguraldissertation Zur Erlangung der Würde eines Doktors der Philosophie vorgelegt der Philosophisch-Naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Universität Basel von Aiping Schuchert-Shi aus Trubschachen (BE), Schweiz Basel, 2009 Genehmigt von der Philosophisch-Naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät Auf Antrag der Herren Prof. Dr. Peter C. Hauser und Prof. Dr. Hans-Rudolf Schmutz-Bühlman Basel, den 25....»

«QUANTIFYING THE IMPACT OF REAL-TIME INFORMATION ON TRANSIT RIDERSHIP A Dissertation Presented to The Academic Faculty by Candace Elizabeth Brakewood In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the School of Civil & Environmental Engineering Georgia Institute of Technology August 2014 Copyright © Candace Elizabeth Brakewood 2014 QUANTIFYING THE IMPACT OF REAL-TIME INFORMATION ON TRANSIT RIDERSHIP Approved by: Dr. Kari Watkins, Advisor Dr. Sean Barbeau...»

«Dyadic Coping in Late Adolescent Couples Thesis (cumulative thesis) Presented to the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences of the University of Zurich for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Christina Jessica Breitenstein Accepted in the Spring Term 2015 on the Recommendation of the Doctoral Committee: Prof. Dr. Guy Bodenmann (main advisor) Prof. Dr. Susanne Walitza Zurich, 2015 AKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost, I would like to thank Professor Guy Bodenmann for the opportunity to write this...»

«DIPLOMARBEIT Titel der Diplomarbeit Labrang Nyingba Ein Stadtpalais in Lhasa, im Kontext der profanen Architektur Tibets Verfasserin Lisa Schuhmeister angestrebter akademischer Grad Magistra der Philosophie (Mag. Phil.) Wien, 2012 Studienkennzahl lt. Studienblatt: A 315 Studienrichtung lt. Studienblatt: Kunstgeschichte Betreuerin: Univ.-Prof. Dr. Deborah Klimburg-Salter Ich widme diese Arbeit André Alexander, für all seine Hinweise und seine Inspiration. Danksagung Allen voran möchte ich...»

«Cutting off Mediation Agamben as Master Thinker Astrid Deuber-Mankowsky Translated by Catharine Diehl Once again there appears to be a need for philosophy in the strong sense of the word. This at least is suggested by the international success of the theses of Giorgio Agamben. In his three-volume Homo Sacer, the Italian philosopher has presented a new attempt at a critique of violence as a fundamental critique of Western thought. The Italian original of the first volume was published as early...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.abstract.xlibx.info - Free e-library - Abstract, dissertation, book

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.